A Skeptics Guide to Homeopathy

Homeopathy Week is upon us! To celebrate, here is our view on Homeopathy. (This and many other discussion topics can be found at our  “Useful Info” link).

- – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – -

Homeopathy is an “alternative medicine” invented in the early 19th century by German doctor Samuel Hahnemann. Despite numerous experiments showing homeopathy to have no effect, it has become a multi-million dollar international industry with its own special rules in advertising law.

In the 19th century, homeopathy was seen as a welcome alternative to dangerous medical practices of the time such as blistering, purges, leeches, and blood-letting. Although homeopathy has declined with advances in mainstream medicine, many people are nervous about the complex array of medicines that they do not understand, and which may have adverse side-effects. To them, homeopathy sounds great. Homeopathic remedies are advertised as safe. They have no side-effects, you can’t overdose, they are non habit-forming, and have no “use by” date. Why?

Homeopathic preparations contain no medicine. Some people feel better when they take homeopathic potions or pills. Some people don’t. In the modern world it’s easy to think that every time we are sick we should take medicines to make us better, (despite the fact that conditions like colds, ‘flu and hangovers run their course and go away without medical intervention). Maybe homeopathic potions don’t work, but some people just feel the need to take something so that they can feel confident and in control. This well-known phenomenon is known as the “placebo” or “sugar pill” effect.

In support of homeopathy, practitioners claim unique, special laws which defy common sense and sound suspiciously like magic spells.

“Like Cures Like” – Homeopaths believe that if you take a substance that affects humans in a certain way, and subject it to homeopathic dilution, it becomes a potion that cures those effects. For example: pollen triggers hay-fever, so a homeopathic dilution of pollen must cure hay-fever. Coffee keeps people awake, so its homeopathic dilution must cure insomnia.

“Homeopathic Dilution” – If you take a mixture and keep adding water, the mixture will get progressively weaker. Any effect the mixture has would be expected to decrease. Homeopaths, on the other hand, claim that if you shake or tap the container a certain number of times after each dilution, the healing effect of the mixture will in fact increase. Claiming the potions are getting stronger, homeopaths usually dilute them to such a degree that you’d need to drink more than an ocean’s worth to be sure of getting just one molecule of the active ingredient. A bottle of pills or potion will contain only the diluting substance (usually water, alcohol or lactose), and none of the healing substance.

One typical homeopathic medication, the  ‘flu remedy, Oscillococcinum, starts with duck’s liver. The liver mixture is diluted to the ratio of one part in 10400. At that rate, one duck is easily enough to make enough anti-‘flu “medicine” to satisfy the world’s population many times over; in fact it’s so dilute that if you were to prepare the product with only one molecule of the duck liver, it would produce more than enough ‘flu potion to fill the known universe. This product reaps $20 million each year. (The unlucky duck has been dubbed “The Twenty Million Dollar Duck.”) The manufacturers don’t show the quantities of ingredients on packets of homeopathic products; they show dilutions in a special code. This is because the high dilutions ensure the product will actually contain no active ingredients! The duck liver dilution in Oscillococcinum is written as 200C. This means the mixture has undergone a sequence of two hundred “C” dilutions. Each “C” dilution is a process where a mixture is diluted by 1:100 and then shaken exactly one hundred times. So a 1C mixture is one hundred times weaker than the original; a 2C dilution is ten thousand times weaker, and so on. So the 200C Oscillococcinum preparation has been diluted to 1 part in

1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000.

Trust us; we are not making this up! Chemically, that’s just pure water.

Note that each dilution must be followed by exactly one hundred shakes performed in exactly the right way. This makes no sense.

Modern homeopaths cannot deny that their potions are too dilute to contain anything but water, and so they have made the claim that water “remembers” their initial ingredients, and behaves in the healing process as if those chemicals were still there. This claim is wishful thinking that has no basis in scientific study.

Does it matter? – Firstly, there are more homeopathic remedies around than you might think. Often they are freely available on pharmacy shelves, and unless you are aware of labelling codes, you may not know that you are paying “top dollar” for seductively packaged sugar pills or water. Secondly, there is the danger that seriously ill people will use homeopathic remedies instead of effective prescription medicine. Although current laws generally allow ineffective potions and pills to be sold in chemists and health food shops around Australia, the authorities in 2002 acted on notification from the Australian Skeptics to ban sales of homeopathic potions that claimed to be 200C (see above) vaccines against the deadly meningococcal disease and hepatitis B.

Things to consider:

  • If homeopathic ingredients are too dilute to be detected, then how can we be sure the pills contain the ingredients listed on the packets? How could we even know that the ingredients were used to make the remedies? During the infamous PAN Pharmaceuticals case, incorrect quantities of ingredients were at the heart of the recall.
  • If the labels fell off two bottles of homeopathic pills, how could you work out which was which?
  • A single homeopathic potion is often claimed to contain the same ingredient twice, at two different dilutions, providing two different effects. Is this possible?
  • How can homeopaths ensure that the water for their potions remembers their special ingredients and none of the other chemicals it has come into contact with before or during their production process?

For more information regarding homeopathy:

1800 666 996      www.skeptics.com.au/vic

HOMEOPATHY  POSTER

4 Responses to A Skeptics Guide to Homeopathy

  1. Terry Kelly says:

    “Alternative medicine” should be called “alternative to medicine”. It’s not just a different type of medicine, it’s just not medicine.

  2. Matt says:

    Good point, Terry.
    As Tim Minchin says: alternative medicine either hasn’t been shown to work, or HAS been shown NOT to work.
    Medicine that HAS been shown to work is just called … medicine.

  3. Russell says:

    It’s easy to criticise what you don’t understand. That’s what I did, until on a friends recommendation I tried Homeopathy for myself.
    The results that I’ve experienced personally and seen in others with Homeopathy are amazing. When my baby daughter was crying at night with teething problems the correct homeopathic medicine had her sleeping peacefully in minutes. Years later when she was crying with ear ache we had the same result. Distressed and crying one minute peacefully sleeping a few minutes later. The ear ache was gone within 24 hours. And because there are no toxic chemicals there are no side effects.
    Had we used antibiotics we would have had to wait a day or two for a result and risked thrush, stomach pains, permanent damage to teeth and a host of other side effects.
    After my own experience of severe side effects from conventional medicines which included Stomach Ulcers, Kidney & Liver damage and Digestive issues I didn’t want to keep swapping one temporary symptom for other chronic health problems as I had with the so called scientifically proven pharmaceutical drugs. Yes pharmaceutical drugs are tested, but mainly by the same companies who make billions from the sale of the drugs. Several of which have paid huge fines for falsifying test results, hiding known dangers that cost thousands of lives and marketing drugs for purposes that they were not designed or tested for. See http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2010/05/20/drug-company-to-pay-half-a-billion-dollar-fine-for-illegal-marketing.aspx
    What most people fail to understand is the sophisticated ploys that drug company giants are using to manipulate and deceive them from the truth. In fact this deception is frequently criminal as many drug companies were listed in the top 100 Corporate Criminal List. They would love all competition from Homeopathy and all Natural therapies to be gone, and spend hundreds of millions on lobbying and propaganda with that aim.
    Say what you want, but if you were really scientific you’d find a good homeopath and try it for yourself. I was skeptical until I tried them for myself.
    Russell

    • malvickers says:

      “When you don’t understand”…. what? The post is well researched is it not? Is there anything wrong with the facts in the article?

      It may have worked for you, however you’re a sample size of one. What’s the control here, i.e. how do you know if you didn’t take Homeopathy you wouldn’t have got better anyway? And how did you rule out confirmation bias?

      Here are anecdotes (just as valid as your anecdotes) of people believing in and taking homeopathy. The results where: contracted malaria, brain injury, misdiagnosis and death.

      http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html

      Does the post say real medicines don’t have side effects? Have you considered this possibility? -The reason homeopathy doesn’t have side effects is because there might not be anything in it?

      Skeptics do also criticize drug companies where it’s warranted.

      “……ploys that drug company giants are using to manipulate and deceive them from the truth.” A giant conspiracy eh? Did you know? Lots of drug companies are now making homeopathy. Why? Because they can make lots of money from nothing but sugar and water, you don’t need to spend money testing it, you have a ready market of believers willing to buy into the “all natural” and “ancient wisdom” fallacies, the directors say, we’re here to make money for our shareholders, if we don’t do it, someone else will.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 98 other followers

%d bloggers like this: